Precision Drilling and Stewarding your Strategic Relationships
This is an older case, but this case triggered some reflections on stewardship in dispute resolution. Precision Drilling Canada Limited Partnership v Yangarra Resources Ltd., 2017 ABCA 378 stayed with me as a strong example of how legal drafting, operational conduct, and relationship management can converge under pressure.
What stood out to me is the tension between a literal reading of the knock-for-knock (K4K) provision and the broader question of what the law ought to allow where the surrounding conduct is alleged to undermine the contractual relationship itself.
Case snapshot: Yangarra alleged that it lost its wells as a result of Precision’s use of drilling mud containing sulfamic acid instead of caustic potash, and the subsequent fraudulent concealment of that mistake. Precision relied on the K4K provision to seek payment for its services, while Yangarra argued that the alleged non-disclosure and subsequent reporting of the mud as satisfactory raised fraud and reckless misrepresentation concerns.
Notably, the Alberta Court of Appeal did not finally decide whether the K4K clause could shield Precision from a fraud-based claim. Instead, it left open the possibility that proven fraudulent or reckless misrepresentation could render the clause unenforceable on public policy grounds.
That appellate nuance is important.
When the K4K clause is broad but silent on carve-outs such as fraud, gross negligence, wilful misconduct, or specific reporting breaches, the dispute can shift from what the contract says to the more difficult question of what the law is — and what it ought to be in light of the parties’ conduct and public policy.
In my view, practical lessons from this case include the importance of a solid evidentiary record, contractual relationship management, and what if analysis:
What if the agreement had included:
- express carve-outs for fraud and gross negligence, coupled with contractual and technical oversight mechanisms (particularly important)
- mandatory incident reporting
- time-stamped treatment logs
- a written mud program with hold points
- record preservation obligations
Would these provisions have prevented the dispute in the first instance?
Perhaps. Perhaps not.
But they could have clarified escalation pathways, strengthened the evidentiary record and discovery (questioning) process, and reduced the need for a court to infer intention from an incomplete factual matrix.
In many disputes, the issue is not only who bears the risk, but also:
How was the relationship managed — and documented — before and after the risk materialized?
That is often where liability, relationship management, and commercial outcomes begin to diverge.
Curious to hear from others in contracts, disputes, and project delivery: which single contractual safeguard do you find most effective in preventing operational disputes from escalating into litigation – if it is avoidable?
Joy Akaa is a contract lawyer at Access Law, which focuses on allowing the average Canadian to Access the Law to resolve their interpersonal disputes. While we focus on the underdog, we celebrate the poverty-reducing power of transparent, rules-based, free markets. We are happy to discuss legal services for Canadian businesses.
#KnockForKnock #ContractLaw #CommercialLaw #RiskAllocation #EnergyLaw #ConstructionLaw #InHouseCounsel #LegalRiskManagement